Skip to main content

Glenfarclas vs Mortlach - A Whisky Lover's Dilemma

Here we have the ultimate matchup! Glenfarclas vs Mortlach - 12 year old variety. Both are entry-level whiskeys from distilleries known for rich, sherried whiskies, but they seem to take different paths - Mortlach with its unique 2.81 times distillation and meaty profile, Glenfarclas with its traditional family-owned approach. 

In this article, we'll dive deep into the history, production methods, and tasting notes of these two Speyside single malts to help you understand their unique characteristics and decide which one comes out on top as your go-to dram.

Glenfarclas Distillery Overview

Glenfarclas is a renowned Speyside distillery with a rich history dating back to 1836. Located in Ballindalloch, Banffshire, just a mile from the River Spey, it sits in the heart of Scotland’s whisky-producing region. The distillery has been family-owned and operated by the Grant family since 1865, making it one of the few remaining independent, family-run distilleries in Scotland.
Glenfarclas is known for its traditional approach to whisky-making. The distillery uses direct-fired stills, a practice that has become increasingly rare in the industry. This method is believed to contribute to the distinctive character of their whiskies. Glenfarclas is also notable for its commitment to sherry cask maturation, which plays a significant role in shaping the flavour profile of their expressions.

Glenfarclas 12 Year Old: Tasting Notes and Characteristics

The Glenfarclas 12 Year Old is a well-regarded entry in the distillery’s core range. Here are the key characteristics and tasting notes.

Glenfarclas 12 Year Old

Region
Speyside, Scotland
Age
12 years old
Alcohol by Volume (ABV)
43%
Cask type
Matured exclusively in Oloroso sherry casks
🟠
Color
Vibrant amber gold
🏆
Awards
Named "Best Sherried Whisky" in the Single Malt World Cup in 2006

Nose: Rich sherry, dried fruits, toffee, and subtle spices. Palate: Full-bodied, with dominant sherry notes, caramel, nuttiness, and warming spices. Finish: Long and sweet, with gentle oak spice and a hint of smoke.

Key characteristics:
  • Exclusively aged in ex-Oloroso sherry casks
  • Family-owned distillery with a traditional approach
  • Direct-fired stills for unique character
  • Exceptional value for a sherried single malt
  • Well-balanced and approachable profile

Glenfarclas 12 is a classic Speyside sherried malt showcasing the distillery's commitment to quality and tradition.

Mortlach Distillery Overview

Mortlach is a historic Speyside distillery located in Dufftown, the heart of Scotland's whisky country. Founded in 1823, it is one of the oldest legal distilleries in Scotland. Mortlach is known for its unique distillation process, which involves a complex system of six stills of varying shapes and sizes. This unusual configuration is often referred to as "The Way" and contributes to the distinct character of Mortlach whiskies. 

The distillery's style is often described as "meaty" or "savoury," setting it apart from other Speyside malts. Mortlach whiskies are typically full-bodied and complex, with a rich, robust character that has earned the distillery the nickname "The Beast of Dufftown."

Mortlach 12 Year Old: Tasting Notes and Characteristics

Mortlach 12 Year Old

Region
Speyside, Scotland
Age
12 years old
Alcohol by Volume (ABV)
43.4%
Nickname
"The Wee Witchie"
Cask type
Double cask matured in European and American oak

Nose: Honey, vanilla, fresh fruits (apple and pear), and a hint of spice. Palate: Medium-bodied, with notes of citrus, honey, vanilla, and a subtle meaty character. Smooth and well-balanced. Finish: Medium length, with lingering sweetness, gentle spices, and a touch of oak. Key characteristics:

  1. Aged in a combination of ex-bourbon and ex-sherry casks
  2. Unique 2.81 times distillation process for a distinct flavour profile

Head-to-Head Comparison

    When it comes to the battle of the 12-year-olds, Glenfarclas and Mortlach bring their unique personalities to the table. Glenfarclas, with its full-on sherry charm, is like a warm hug from your favourite grandma - comforting, sweet, and full of rich, dried fruit flavours. On the other hand, Mortlach, with its meaty, savoury character, is like a hearty steak dinner - bold, satisfying, and unapologetically robust.
      Glenfarclas 12 lures you in with its inviting nose of raisins, toffee, and subtle spices, while Mortlach 12 greets you with a more delicate bouquet of honey, fresh fruits, and a hint of its signature meatiness. On the palate, Glenfarclas envelops your taste buds with a luscious, full-bodied sherried experience, while Mortlach opts for a medium-bodied, well-balanced approach, allowing its citrusy sweetness and savoury undertones to shine through.
        The unique selling points of each whisky are clear: Glenfarclas 12 is the ultimate sherry bomb, offering exceptional value for those seeking a rich, fruity dram. Mortlach 12, on the other hand, serves as an accessible introduction to the distillery's distinctive style, showcasing its meaty character in a more approachable format.

          The Verdict

            As a self-proclaimed whisky enthusiast with a penchant for sherried drams, I must admit that Glenfarclas 12 has a special place in my heart. Its unapologetic sherry influence and well-rounded profile make it my go-to choice when I'm in the mood for a comforting, indulgent whisky experience.
              However, I cannot discount the allure of Mortlach 12's unique character. Its savoury, meaty notes add an intriguing dimension to the classic Speyside flavour profile, making it a compelling choice for those looking to venture off the beaten path.
                Ultimately, the choice between these two whiskies comes down to personal preference. Whether you're a die-hard sherry fan or an adventurous whisky explorer, both Glenfarclas 12 and Mortlach 12 offer exceptional quality and distinct personalities that are sure to captivate your senses. My advice? Try them both and let your taste buds be the judge!

                Your next great whisky adventure awaits!

                Looking for more Whisky Reviews. Take a look at our best whisky under 50 guide. 
                Labels:

                Popular posts from this blog

                MacBook Pro Docking Station Review 2024: UGREEN Revodok Pro 313

                Looking for the best MacBook Pro docking station? After testing 10 popular MacBook dock stations in our UK lab, we've discovered why the UGREEN Revodok Pro 313 might be the ultimate docking station for your MacBook Pro. Picture this: You're staring at your powerful MacBook Pro, but its limited ports are holding you back. Frustrating, isn't it? Here's something every MacBook Pro user knows: Apple's minimalist design means we need a reliable docking station to unlock our device's full potential. But with so many MacBook dock stations flooding the market, finding the best one can feel overwhelming. That's why I spent three weeks putting the UGREEN Revodok Pro 313 through its paces. And what I discovered might surprise you. Quick Verdict: Why This MacBook Pro Dock Stands Out As someone who's reviewed MacBook docking stations for over five years, here's what makes the Revodok Pro 313 special: ...
                Read more

                Best Whisky Under £50: Expert UK Guide (2024) | Top Single Malts

                Looking for a great whisky that won't break the bank? As someone who's passionate about whisky and loves sharing that knowledge with others, I've carefully selected the best whiskies under 50 that deliver good value for money. Here's what makes this guide different: instead of overwhelming you with dozens of options, I'm focusing on three carefully chosen whiskies that consistently impress both newcomers and enthusiasts alike. How We Selected These Whiskies Let me be transparent about our selection criteria: Available for under £50 in most supermarkets Consistently well-reviewed by consumers Readily available in most liquor stores and Amazon Suitable for both sipping neat and in cocktails Proven gift-giving track record Best Overall Whisky Under £50: The Glenlivet Founder's Reserve Single Malt Scotch Whisky    The Glenlivet Founder...
                Read more

                The Best External Hard Drive for Mac Video Editing: A Budget-Friendly Solution

                Are you a Mac video editor struggling with storage space? You're not alone. When I got my M1 MacBook Pro, I was blown away by its video editing performance. But there was just one problem: the 256GB storage felt impossibly small for 4K video projects. Here's the good news: I've found an incredibly cost-effective solution that won't break the bank. In fact, it costs less than £20 The Challenge: Finding an Affordable External Drive for Mac Video Editing When it comes to video editing on a Mac, you need three essential things from your external drive: Lightning-fast transfer speeds Reliable performance Mac compatibility Most decent options at Currys or John Lewis will set you back hundreds of pounds. But what if I told you there's a budget-friendly alternative that actually does the job? The Solution: LEMORELE M.2 NVMe SSD Enclosure After thoroughly looking through Amazon, I discovered the LEMORELE M.2 NVMe SSD enclosure . Here's why it's proper good: Premium a...
                Read more